Follow Me On Social Media!
Every Thanksgiving ends the same way: a half-eaten pumpkin pie sits in the fridge, a slice or two missing, and nobody quite wants another plain slice. The pie is too good to throw away and too familiar to get excited about, so it sits there until someone admits it has gone off and bins it. It does not have to end that way. A leftover pumpkin pie is not a finished dessert. It is an ingredient: a spiced, custardy filling and a buttery crust that can be crumbled, blended, layered, and baked into seven different desserts.
First, How Long Does Leftover Pumpkin Pie Last?
Leftover pumpkin pie keeps three to four days in the fridge, and that window is a safety limit, not a suggestion. Pumpkin pie is a custard pie, made with eggs and milk, and custard pies follow the same rule as other cooked leftovers: the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service says leftovers can be kept in the refrigerator for three to four days, and the FoodSafety.gov cold food storage chart gives the same three-to-four-day figure. Count from the day the pie was baked, not the day you put the leftovers in the fridge, and keep the fridge at 40°F or below.
The freezer gives you more time. A leftover pie, or slices of it, will keep in the freezer for one to two months for best quality. Wrap slices tightly in plastic wrap, then in foil, then in a freezer bag, and label them with the date. Once thawed, use it within three to four days. For the full method, including how to freeze a whole pie and keep the crust crisp, see our guide to freezing pumpkin pie. For a broader look at these windows across the Thanksgiving table, see our guide on how long leftovers last in the fridge.
Pumpkin Pie Truffles (No-Bake, 10 Minutes)
Pumpkin pie truffles are the best remake on this list, and the easiest. Start with two or three slices of leftover pie, filling and crust together. Crumble the pie into a bowl and mix it with your hands until well combined. If the mixture is too dry to hold together, add a spoonful of softened cream cheese, a little at a time, until it binds. Roll the mixture into balls about an inch across, place them on a tray lined with parchment, and chill them in the fridge for at least 30 minutes.
To finish them, melt chocolate in a bowl over a pan of simmering water, or in the microwave in short bursts, stirring between each one. A cake truffle being dipped in melted chocolate is the image to hold in mind: the ball goes in, comes out coated, and sets into a smooth shell. Dip each chilled ball, lift it out with a fork, let the excess drip off, and set it back on the parchment. Let them set in the fridge for 20 minutes. A plate of chocolate truffles with berries is the finished picture, and the reason this remake works so well for a party: it turns a leftover into a dessert that looks deliberate. The same truffle, milkshake, s’mores, and trifle ideas appear in a roundup of seven leftover pumpkin pie ideas, which uses the same methods: crumble, mix, roll, chill, and dip.
Pumpkin Pie Milkshake
A pumpkin pie milkshake is the fastest remake on this list, and the best use for a single leftover slice. It takes five minutes, a blender, and three ingredients you already have. Put one slice of leftover pumpkin pie, crust and all, into a blender, add two to three scoops of vanilla ice cream and a quarter cup of milk, and blend until smooth. Pour it into a tall glass, top it with whipped cream, and drizzle it with caramel or chocolate syrup. That is the whole recipe. Scoops of vanilla ice cream are the starting point, and the pie does the rest: the filling gives the shake its flavour and colour, the crust gives it body, and the ice cream makes it thick and cold. If the shake is too thick, add milk a splash at a time. If it is too thin, add another scoop of ice cream. The milkshake is also the best remake for a small amount of pie. One slice makes one generous shake, two slices make two, and there is no need to scale up or down. Make the shake on Friday or Saturday, while the pie is still fresh, and it will taste like a dessert you planned, not a rescue job.
Pumpkin Pie Parfait
A pumpkin pie parfait is the prettiest remake on this list, and the one that takes the least effort for the most effect. A parfait is a layered dessert, and a leftover pie gives you two of the layers for free: the filling and the crust. Scoop the filling out of the crust, or crumble the whole slice, filling and crust together, into a bowl. Whip some heavy cream with a tiny bit of maple syrup, not too much, because the pie is already sweet. Toast the crumbled crust separately in a dry pan with a little butter, until it is crispy again. Then layer it in a glass: filling, whipped cream, toasted crust, and repeat until the glass is full. Finish with a dollop of cream, a sprinkle of cinnamon, and a few toasted pecans.
The parfait works because it separates the pie into its parts and rebuilds them in a better order. The filling, on its own, is a smooth, spiced custard. The crust, toasted, is a crisp, buttery crumb. The cream, whipped, is light and cold. Layered together, they taste like a deconstructed pie, and they look far more impressive than a slice on a plate. A chocolate cake surrounded by bowls of sprinkles, cream cheese, and cocoa is a good picture of the parfait station: small bowls, a few ingredients, and a dessert that comes together by layering rather than cooking.
Pumpkin Pie Trifle
A pumpkin pie trifle is the parfait scaled up for a crowd, and the best remake for a whole leftover pie. A trifle is a layered dessert in a large glass bowl, built the same way as the parfait, with more of everything. Crumble the pie, filling and crust together, into a large bowl. Whip cream with a little maple syrup. Toast the crumbled crust in a pan with butter until crisp. Then layer it in a trifle bowl: crumbled pie, whipped cream, toasted crust, and repeat until the bowl is full. A whole cake beside a plate of finished chocolate truffles is the image of a dessert made for sharing, and a trifle is exactly that: a big, generous bowl that feeds eight people and looks like a centrepiece. Finish the top with a thick layer of cream, a sprinkle of cinnamon, and a ring of toasted pecans or crushed gingersnaps. The trifle is also the best remake for a pie that is slightly past its best. A pie that is a little dry or soft will disappear into the layers, and no one will know. It is a forgiving dessert, and the reason a whole leftover pie is not a problem. It is a trifle waiting to happen.
Pumpkin Pie S’mores
Pumpkin pie s’mores are the most fun remake on this list, and the best use for the crust. A s’more is a sandwich, and a pumpkin pie s’more replaces the chocolate bar with a slice of pie. Take a graham cracker, spread a thick layer of pumpkin pie filling on it, add a toasted marshmallow, and top it with a second graham cracker. Press gently, and the warm marshmallow will melt the filling slightly, and the whole thing will hold together just long enough to eat. A plated chocolate lava cake with vanilla ice cream and raspberries is the picture of the warm-and-gooey dessert this is aiming for: hot, soft, and a little messy.
There are a few ways to build a pumpkin pie s’more, and the best one depends on what you have left. The s’more is best eaten warm, within a few minutes of assembling, because the marshmallow cools and firms up quickly. It is a dessert for a cold evening, a fire, and a group of people standing around with sticky fingers. It is also a good way to use up a pie when there are children around, because it turns a leftover into a project. Let them build their own, and the pie will be gone before you have finished cleaning up.
Pumpkin Pie Cookies and French Toast Bake
Pumpkin pie cookies and a French toast bake are the two cooked remakes on this list, and the best use for a pie that needs a little help. For the cookies, crumble two slices of leftover pie into a bowl, filling and crust together, and mix in a spoonful of flour and a pinch of baking powder until the mixture holds together. Roll it into balls, flatten them slightly, and bake at 350°F for 12 to 15 minutes, until the edges are set and the tops are lightly golden. The cookies will be soft, spiced, and a little chewy, with the crust giving them a buttery crumb.
The French toast bake turns a dessert into a breakfast, and it feeds four people from a single leftover pie. Cut the pie into cubes, place them in a buttered baking dish, and pour over a custard made from two eggs, a cup of milk, a teaspoon of vanilla, and a pinch of cinnamon. A stack of French toast wrapped in plastic on a refrigerator shelf is the image of this dish waiting for the morning. Let the cubes soak for 20 minutes, then bake at 350°F for 30 to 35 minutes, until the custard is set and the top is golden. Serve it warm, with maple syrup and a dusting of powdered sugar.
How to Store Leftover Pumpkin Pie (Fridge and Freezer)
Storing leftover pumpkin pie properly is what makes all of the remakes above possible, because a pie that has dried out or picked up fridge odours will not remake well. In the fridge, cover the pie tightly with plastic wrap, or transfer slices to an airtight container, and keep it at 40°F or below. A ramekin of lava cake on a refrigerator shelf is a good picture of what proper storage looks like: a single serving, covered, and kept cold. The fridge window is three to four days from the day the pie was baked, and the freezer window is one to two months for best quality. Wrap slices tightly in plastic wrap, then in foil, then in a freezer bag, and label them with the date. Thaw a frozen pie overnight in the fridge, and use it within three to four days of thawing. Slices are options. Refrigerate it within two hours of serving, or within one hour if the room is above 90°F. For a broader look at how these windows fit together, see our guide on how long leftovers last in the fridge, and for the rest of the Thanksgiving leftovers, see our ideas for leftover Brussels sprouts and our leftover turkey shepherd’s pie. The pie is the sweetest leftover on the table, and it deserves the same care as the savoury ones.
The Bottom Line
A leftover pumpkin pie is not a problem. It is seven desserts waiting to happen, and the only thing standing between the pie in the fridge and a plate of truffles is ten minutes and a bowl of melted chocolate. The remakes are simple. Crumble the pie with a little cream cheese, roll it into balls, chill them, and dip them in melted chocolate for truffles. Blend a slice with vanilla ice cream and milk for a milkshake. Layer the filling, whipped cream, and toasted crust in a glass for a parfait, or in a big bowl for a trifle. Spread the filling on a graham cracker with a toasted marshmallow for a s’more. Crumble the pie into cookies, or cube it, soak it in an egg-milk custard, and bake it into a French toast bake.

Ghani is the founder of TwiceTasty and a passionate home cook who believes no meal should go to waste. What started as a personal mission to transform leftovers into exciting new dishes has grown into a community of food lovers who share the same philosophy.
